(267) 389-9644
Stone chimney with a metal cap rising beside the shingled roof of a stone house

How should a serpentine or old stone chimney in Chester County be repaired?

Gently, and with a soft, lime-rich mortar. The National Park Service notes that serpentine absorbs water and breaks down through freeze and thaw, and that it is acid-sensitive and no longer quarried for building. Hard mortar, acid cleaners and abrasive cleaning speed up the damage, so repairs should keep the joints softer than the stone.

Philly Chimney & Fireplace Repair · November 8, 2026

The green stone of West Chester

Serpentine is the green stone you see on older buildings around West Chester. The National Park Service's Technical Note Masonry No. 1 says it was used for facades and trim in Philadelphia and in rural areas near the quarries, such as Chester County.

Westtown Township's winter 2023–24 newsletter traces much of it to Brinton's Quarry, also called the Serpentine Ridge Quarry, which produced 500,000 cubic yards between 1870 and 1888. The newsletter points to examples on the West Chester University campus and on New Street, and notes that Penn's College Hall in Philadelphia is built of it too. West Chester's HARB guidelines name Horticultural Hall at 225 N. High Street, designed by Thomas U. Walter in 1848.

Why serpentine wears out

The NPS note describes serpentine as fibrous rather than tightly consolidated, so it soaks up water. That water expands and contracts with every freeze and thaw, which speeds up the stone's breakdown. The stone is also sensitive to acid, and it is no longer quarried for exterior use, so a lost piece cannot simply be cut fresh.

Chester County's climate is hard on it. NOAA's 1991–2020 normals for the West Chester station count about 131 nights a year at or below freezing, compared with about 62 in Center City, along with about 30.5 inches of snow and about 51 inches of total precipitation. By our own count from two NOAA fields, that works out to about 115 freeze-thaw swings a year.

Other old stone chimneys

Not every stone chimney here is serpentine. Bucks County has a long run of stone houses from the 1700s and 1800s, and Wikipedia notes rowhouses faced with Wissahickon schist in Mayfair and Mount Airy. How any one fieldstone chimney was built, lined or mortared varies, so we confirm what is there rather than assume.

NPS Preservation Brief 2 makes a point that applies to all of them: even buildings of wood or other materials usually have masonry foundations or chimneys, and the fresh joint material ought to be weaker than the stone and let moisture pass more easily than it does.

What helps, and what hurts

These habits come straight from the NPS guidance and West Chester's HARB guidelines:

  • Use a mortar that is softer than the stone and does not carry a high portland cement content. HARB's recommended mix for historic chimney brick is 1 white portland : 1 lime : 5 sand.
  • Rake old joints by hand. Grinders chip soft stone edges.
  • Keep acid cleaners off serpentine; the NPS lists it as acid-sensitive.
  • Skip abrasive blasting and film-forming coatings that trap water inside.
  • Fix the crown and cap first, so less water enters from the top.

How we approach a stone chimney

The inspection and mortar check are free. We identify the stone, check how deep the joints have eroded, look at the crown and flashing, and photograph every face. Repointing in a soft, lime-rich mortar typically runs $500–$2,500. Replacing failed stone or spalled brick typically runs $1,000–$3,500, and with serpentine the hard part is finding salvaged stone that matches; if we cannot find a match, we tell you before work begins.

In West Chester borough, chimney work on a historic property falls under HARB review. We assemble the photos, a mortar sample and a written scope with you for that HARB file.

Answers

Follow-up questions

Can serpentine be replaced with new stone?

Not with new serpentine, since the NPS notes it is no longer quarried for exterior use. Repairs rely on salvaged stone or a substitute chosen with the local review board where one applies.

Why is my green stone chimney flaking?

Serpentine absorbs water, and freeze-thaw cycles break it down. Hard mortar or a coating that traps water makes it worse.

Do fieldstone chimneys need a liner?

It depends on what the chimney vents and how it was built. Current code calls for masonry chimneys to be lined, and we check each one rather than assume.

Rooftops of brick row houses in the foreground with the Center City Philadelphia skyline behind, on a sunny day

Schedule

Choose a morning or an afternoon.

Sunday through Friday, arrival between 8 and 11, 11 and 2, or 2 and 5. The look costs nothing, and a person phones you the day before.

Or call (267) 389-9644

Call (267) 389-9644